forum

Picturing the Great Depression and the New Deal – Seeing Beyond Hard Times

Many of the images we have seen so far reflect contemporary use of visual images to call viewers to action. Documentary photography often served the purpose of exposé, confronting viewers with images of poverty as an appeal to conscience. Graphics, prints, and posters too were often designed and distributed to encourage change or present the positive effects of New Deal programs. Radical artists, writers, and playwrights rejected the modernist ideal of “art for art’s sake” to use their creative imaginations for political purposes—to use “art as a weapon” in political struggles.

At the same time, New Deal era visual culture also includes a commitment to use art to reassure people in an anxious time and to place before them images of hope and solace. Much of the public art of the period did exactly that, in particular the work of the Treasury Section of Fine Arts, which commissioned murals and sculpture for public buildings. Section projects were most commonly small town post offices, but also included court houses and the monumental public buildings that housed the great expansion of government workers who administered New Deal programs. The Federal Art Project, part of the Works Progress Administration, also supervised public art in municipal auditoriums, public schools, veterans’ hospitals, prisons, and city halls built during the period.

Arthur Getz, "Harvest," post office mural, Bronson, Michigan.

Arthur Getz, "Harvest," post office mural, Bronson, Michigan.

Seymour Fogel, "People of the Soil," Cabridge, Minnesota.

Seymour Fogel, "People of the Soil," Cambridge, Minnesota.

Joseph Coletti, "Farmers and Geese," Mansfield, Massachusetts.

Joseph Coletti, "Farmers and Geese," Mansfield, Massachusetts.

Post office murals and sculpture often relied on common conventions of composition. What do these three have in common? What kind of work is shown? New Deal era depictions of paid work usually focus on male figures, often in poses emphasizing strength and skill. Women workers are much less commonly represented, and these images seldom show men and women working together.

Many examples of public art and theater reveal artists and playwrights in search of a usable past—exploring historical themes that might offer reassurance and encouragement. One very common subject is the American frontier.

Sidney Loeb, "Pioneer Family," Royal Oak, Michigan.

Sidney Loeb, "Pioneer Family," Royal Oak, Michigan.

William S. McCall, "Early Settlers Weighing Cotton," Montevallo, Alabama.

William S. McCall, "Early Settlers Weighing Cotton," Montevallo, Alabama.

Notice the similar compositions in these representations of frontier life, and the way men’s and women’s activities are shown. The frontier has rich and enduring associations for American popular culture. What do you think New Deal era viewers might have found inspiring in this history?

The Civil War was another common historical subject. With its story of national division, enduring bitterness, and staggering bloodshed, this might seem an unlikely choice. As you view these images, consider what themes are suggested in them.

melosh51The young Lincoln was a favorite subject. James Hansen’s sculpture for the Los Angeles Post Office and Courthouse shows Lincoln as a thoughtful and somewhat vulnerable young man.

What in the figure’s pose suggests these qualities? How does this youthful Lincoln compare with more well known representations?

Louis Slobodkin, "Young Abraham Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska.

A statue of young Lincoln, by Louis Slobodkin and also done during this period, in the Department of the Interior. A copy was later made by the Justice and Law Enforcement Center of the City-County Building in Lincoln, Nebraska, where it is called “The Rail Joiner.” Slobodkin’s figure also stands with one knee bent and head tilted down.

What does this convey?

ptg2Ellsworth Prosty Conkle’s play, Prologue to Glory, was performed many times during the period.

Compare the figure in this Federal Theatre Project poster to the one in Hansen’s sculpture.

Why do you think the young Lincoln might have appealed to Americans of the 1930s?

One Comment

  1. Josh Brown
    Posted March 26, 2009 at 7:16 am | Permalink

    If you’re in the vicinity of central Pennsylvania on May 5th, there is an interesting symposium on “Labor’s Legacy: Pennsylvania Industrial Art,” including a number of speakers on 1930s activist and public art. The event includes a visit to an exhibit at the State Museum of Pennsylvania at Harrisburg, “A Common Canvas: Pennsylvania’s New Deal Post Office Murals.” For more information: http://www.centrecountyhistory.org/eventsexhibits/symposium.html